How to Prepare for a Defense Medical Examination in a FELA Case

If you have filed a FELA claim after a railroad injury, you will likely be asked to attend a defense medical examination, usually called a DME. This is a physical examination of an injured railroad worker conducted by a physician the rail company selects to help the railroad defend against your claim. Understanding what this exam is and how to handle it can make a meaningful difference in your case. A FELA attorney can prepare you and make sure it doesn’t undermine your claim.

“Independent” Is a Misnomer

You may also hear this exam called an IME, or independent medical examination. Historically, the “I” stood for “insurance,” which is telling, because there is very little independent about it. The physician was chosen by the railroad, and that doctor is being paid to help the railroad’s defense.

Keeping that reality in mind is the right frame of mind to walk in with. The examining doctor is not your treating physician and is not focused on your recovery. Their role is to produce findings the railroad can use to minimize your claim. Recognizing that from the outset helps you stay guarded and careful throughout the exam.

Before the Exam

Before your DME, ask your lawyer for detailed guidance tailored to your case. As a general matter, you should not bring any documentation beyond a valid photo ID. The exam is not meant to be a full inquiry into how your accident happened; that is what the deposition is for. Your job is to give a simple, basic explanation of how you were injured, such as a concussion or a soft-tissue injury, and to describe the symptoms you are currently experiencing. The physician will usually take you through a few standard tests designed to assess your physical limitations.

What to Do During the Exam

How you conduct yourself during the DME matters. Keep these points in mind:

  • Note how much time the doctor actually spends with you
  • Keep track of which tests the doctor actually performs
  • Call your attorney as soon as you leave
  • Be honest, but do not volunteer more than the question asks
  • Be aware that you may be under surveillance before, during, or after the exam
  • Do not fill out any forms

If you cannot reach your attorney right after the exam, write down a few notes while everything is fresh so you can give them an accurate account later.

Details Worth Recording for Your Attorney

Certain specifics are especially useful to report back. Make a note of each of the following:

  • The name of any device used to test you
  • Whether the doctor ignored the part of your body you identified as the problem
  • Whether the doctor rushed through the exam, or examined you without actually touching you
  • Whether the exam was held somewhere other than a doctor’s office or medical facility, such as a hotel conference room

Details like these can reveal a cursory or slanted examination and help your attorney challenge the findings later.

Reviewing the Written Report

When the written DME report is released to your attorney, read it thoroughly and check it carefully for accuracy. Ask yourself:

  • Does the report accurately reflect everything you said, or does it make it look as though you said something you did not?
  • Did the doctor actually do everything the report claims they did?

If anything in the report is unclear, take a copy to your own physician and ask them to explain it. An inaccurate or misleading report is something your attorney needs to know about so it can be addressed.

Why This Matters So Much

It is worth being especially careful about your DME, because unlike your regular doctor, the physician conducting it works for the railroad. That doctor is serving the carrier’s interests, which generally means minimizing your claim, not looking after your health. Walking in prepared, staying guarded, and reporting the details to your attorney afterward are the best ways to keep the exam from being used against you.

Our attorneys bring more than 100 years of combined legal experience to FELA cases, and we know how railroads and their chosen physicians approach these exams. That experience has produced significant results for railroad workers, including an $8.6 million jury verdict, later affirmed by the state’s highest court. Results depend on the facts of each case, but outcomes like that reflect the effort these claims require.

Facing a Defense Medical Exam? Contact Us Today

If you were injured on the job as a railroad worker and have questions about a defense medical examination or any other part of your claim, a FELA attorney at Shapiro, Washburn & Sharp can prepare you and protect your rights. Contact us at 833-997-1774 for a free FELA consultation. We have offices in Virginia Beach, Portsmouth, Suffolk, Hampton, Norfolk, and Chesapeake, and we are ready to put our decades of railroad injury experience to work for you and your family.